BetterPhoto Q&A
Category: New Answers

Photography Question 

Lori Hohenstein
 

Photo Enhancements: CS4 Vs. Elements 8


I have been shooting pics for a long time, and I pride myself on not enhancing my images with Photoshop or other programs. But it seems like lately that most all professionals are "popping" the color on their pictures or tinkering with the natural lighting somehow. I am slowly getting an "if you can't beat them, join them" attitude.
What are the fastest and easiest ways to produce this "hyper-colored" look?


To love this question, log in above
0
March 23, 2010

 
- Carlton Ward

BetterPhoto Member
Contact Carlton Ward
Carlton Ward's Gallery
  Hello Lori,
I know there are many "purists" in regards to photography & digital editing but the fact is that even film images were also processed for color, saturation, brightness, etc.. Many of the tools that Photoshop includes came from the film editors processing tools and techniques. It's just easier to do these processes with digital software. If you shoot a Raw + JPEG as many cameras will do, the Raw image may look a bit flat as it is just unprocessed raw data, where as a JPEG is processed in the camera and will come out of the camera looking better than the raw image. The Raw image needs to be processed to make it come to life. This is a great advantage especially for things like correcting white balance and adjusting exposure.
Doing our own digital editing also allows us to edit an image the way we want it to look and gives us a lot of control from simple edits to extreme manipulations. Its all a matter of taste when it comes to editing, and I have tried many extreme edits just to see how far I can go. If I don't like the end result, I just go back to the original and start it over again.
I don't know what software you have, but Adobe Photoshop is what many people use. It has more tools than you may ever need and something like Adobe Lightroom or Adobe Elements may fill all your editing needs. I have the Canon software that is included with my cameras but I started using Photoshop years before I bought my first Canon, so I never really explored that software.
There are free software programs like GIMP and Picassa. Other choices are Corel Paintshop Pro and Apple Aperture as well.
If you don't have any of these and are looking for a place to start, I would recommend Adobe Elements 8, which is under $100 and will do most anything you will ever need.
I also recommend taking a class as many books will include so many things that will not pertain to what you want to do, but the classes here will focus on exactly the tools you will need and want.
Hope this helps.


To love this comment, log in above
0
March 22, 2010

 

Lori Hohenstein
  HI Carlton - thanks for the help. I do have Photoshop 8.0 and it overwhelms me! Is Lightroom an extra program? I am going to check out the others too.
Thanks!!


To love this comment, log in above
0
March 23, 2010

 

Lynn R. Powers
 
 
 
Hi Lori,
What you have is Photoshop Elements 8 (PSE8), since PS 7 was the last professional program before they started the CS (Creative Suite) series. They are now up to CS4, and CS5 will probably come out during this calendar year. These are $700 programs. PSE8 is the one to keep using since it has many of the same tools that are found in the more advanced programs. Lightroom is less expensive than CS4 but considerably more advanced than PSE8. It is not necessary to upgrade each time Adobe comes out with a new version unless you have such an advanced camera that your program will not read it. I have friends who still use PSE2, and they have Canon 1Ds Mark II cameras. However, the RAW processor in PSE 7 and 8 is much better. Take a course from BP to learn how to use it properly and you will be delighted on how your photos look after 5 minutes of work or less. You are correct that when you do not know how to use it is overwhelming but the instructors take out all the mystery.
Some people used VS, Very Saturated, film when taking photos. It was their style and what they preferred. Many of us didn't. How the colors turn out now is up to you. And the programs let you adjust it any way that you want. You can even make a B&W print if you so desire. As Carlton pointed out, we are doing the same thing that was done in the lab, just the method has changed.
Here is a photo that is as natural as I could get it. But it did take a little work. It had to be cropped, since neither 35mm film or the same format with digital can naturally be enlarged to 8X10, I made it a little brighter, sharpened it so that detail on the rock was visible, burned in the out of focus rock behind his head, added a bit of saturation to enhance the colors slightly and that was it. I just noticed that I should have made his left hand a little darker because it is too light for his complexion. Does this look unnatural to you?

http://www.betterphoto.com/gallery/dynoGallDetail.php?photoID=8827031

You will often find dust bunnies on your sensor. These are easily removed and less time-consuming than working with film.
Best of luck, and TAKE a course. You won't be sorry.


To love this comment, log in above
0
March 23, 2010

 
- Carlton Ward

BetterPhoto Member
Contact Carlton Ward
Carlton Ward's Gallery
  Lori,
Richard Lynch teaches a 4-week course (Photoshop 101) and there are a couple of other ones as well. Like Lynn stated, a short course will make a huge difference and get you on your way. It is actually a lot of fun playing with all the editing tools but to be able to make the image look how you want it to makes the learning curve and effort so worth it.


To love this comment, log in above
0
March 23, 2010

 
- Dr Silly

BetterPhoto Member
Contact Dr Silly
Dr Silly's Gallery
  If you are not a Pro, you will find PSE8 is all you need. Yes, there are things in PS CS3 and CS4 that PSE8 cannot do. But PSE8 is a lot of program. Learn that first before even thinking about any other program. :O)


To love this comment, log in above
0
March 24, 2010

 
- Dennis Flanagan

BetterPhoto Member
Contact Dennis Flanagan
Dennis Flanagan's Gallery
  Go online or to your favorite bookstore and find the Photoshop Elements book by Scott Kelby. His books are excellent for learning how to use Photoshop.


To love this comment, log in above
0
March 24, 2010

 
Log in to respond or ask your own question.